All NFL teams
Full-career context These totals follow Frankie Smith across every NFL team. Draft credit is separated below for each team that selected him.
Games played 103
Games started 4
Weighted career AV 7
Pro Bowls 0
AP1 All-Pro 0
Career seasons 9
Accountability by draft event
What each drafting team received 1992 · Round 4 · #104
ATL draft credit GM Ken Herock
Team games 0
Team starts 0
On-team AV 0
On-team PB / AP1 0 / 0
Terrible -2.05 contribution 55th of 62 picks for this GM
Games: complete career recorded elsewhere. Starts: zero starts from zero team games.
Frankie Smith became a 9-season, 103-game NFL player after going #104. The retained-value model still ranks him 55th of 62 for Ken Herock because ATL only got 0 of those games.
His retained-value contribution score (opportunity plus quality plus recognition, with related outcomes collapsed inside each bucket) is -2.05 . This is a per-pick accountability metric, separate from Ken Herock's leaderboard composite θ.
Full-career context prevents this from being labeled as a bad talent pick: the negative model score is about retained team value, not whether the draft identified an NFL-caliber player.
The walkthrough below shows which bucket carried the pick: playing time, value quality, or league honors.
Opportunity
Did he earn the field?
Games played
0
on drafting team · 103 full-career
Games started
0
on drafting team · 4 full-career
Snap-z
0.0
0 modeled seasons
Quality
Was that time valuable?
On-team AV
0
modeled; full weighted AV 7
AV / 1k snaps
—
snap-era only
AV-rate z
—
position-year adjusted quality
Recognition
Did the league notice?
Pro Bowls
0
all on drafting team
AP1 All-Pro
0 AP1
all on drafting team · AP2 context 0
Data release Published release
2026-08-01-v30-deep-maturity · published 2026-08-01 · drafts 1980–2025 · 190 people in 209 GM-team careers · Multivariate Bayesian drafted-player outcomes model (v30) · maturity-adjusted 95% credible intervals.
This status records the verified public release at the canonical Good GM URL. Methodology · Data & definitions · Public manifest
Did this pick move Ken Herock's grade? The first chart removes the time axis: every Ken Herock pick is sorted by retained contribution across opportunity, quality, and recognition. Frankie Smith totals -2.05 . The second chart breaks that same contribution into the seasons when the evidence arrived. Opportunity and quality can move separately, which keeps high-snap, low-AV profiles from looking cleaner than they are.
Aggregate contribution by player -8 -6 -4 -2 0 +2 +4 201. Anderson #201 · Jamal Anderson · aggregate +4.12 Anderson +4.1 87. Gardner #87 · Moe Gardner · aggregate +2.65 Gardner +2.6 181. Hall #181 · Travis Hall · aggregate +2.41 Hall +2.4 51. Smith #51 · Chuck Smith · aggregate +2.32 Smith +2.3 140. Hoover #140 · Houston Hoover · aggregate +2.03 Hoover +2.0 166. Haynes #166 · Michael Haynes · aggregate +1.64 154. Dixon #154 · Floyd Dixon · aggregate +1.45 145. Pegram #145 · Erric Pegram · aggregate +0.83 45. Emanuel #45 · Bert Emanuel · aggregate +0.77 62. Jones #62 · Keith Jones · aggregate +0.60 138. Thomas #138 · George Thomas · aggregate +0.59 181. Reid #181 · Michael Reid · aggregate +0.54 178. Walker #178 · Darnell Walker · aggregate +0.38 38. Harper #38 · Roger Harper · aggregate +0.36 172. Mitchell #172 · Brian Mitchell · aggregate +0.34 67. Alexander #67 · Harold Alexander · aggregate +0.25 145. Preston #145 · Roell Preston · aggregate +0.24 17. Green #17 · Tim Green · aggregate +0.23 151. Lyons #151 · Mitch Lyons · aggregate +0.13 245. Burrough #245 · John Burrough · aggregate +0.13 111. Klein #111 · Perry Klein · aggregate -0.02 158. Ray #158 · Terry Ray · aggregate -0.02 121. George #121 · Ron George · aggregate -0.08 27. Collins #27 · Shawn Collins · aggregate -0.17 159. Williams #159 · Keith Williams · aggregate -0.18 172. Johnson #172 · Undra Johnson · aggregate -0.24 72. Phillips #72 · Anthony Phillips · aggregate -0.25 125. Mraz #125 · Mark Mraz · aggregate -0.25 138. Houston #138 · Harrison Houston · aggregate -0.31 55. Barnett #55 · Oliver Barnett · aggregate -0.32 139. Pringle #139 · Mike Pringle · aggregate -0.33 182. Paulk #182 · Tim Paulk · aggregate -0.33 186. Tucker #186 · Mark Tucker · aggregate -0.38 121. Redding #121 · Reggie Redding · aggregate -0.44 153. Kiser #153 · Paul Kiser · aggregate -0.56 118. Davis #118 · Mitch Davis · aggregate -0.58 114. Goode #114 · James Goode · aggregate -0.62 27. Conner #27 · Darion Conner · aggregate -0.68 99. Kalaniuvalu #99 · Alai Kalaniuvalu · aggregate -0.72 41. Davis #41 · Ron Davis · aggregate -0.73 77. Styles #77 · Lorenzo Styles · aggregate -0.76 56. Higdon #56 · Alex Higdon · aggregate -0.77 26. Sr. #26 · Devin Bush Sr. · aggregate -0.82 97. Dyke #97 · Ralph Van Dyke · aggregate -0.85 28. Cotton #28 · Marcus Cotton · aggregate -0.85 73. Dinkins #73 · Howard Dinkins · aggregate -0.86 19. Smith #19 · Tony Smith · aggregate -0.95 31. Flowers #31 · Kenny Flowers · aggregate -1.13 38. Norwood #38 · Ralph Norwood · aggregate -1.21 13. Miller #13 · Chris Miller · aggregate -1.44 13. Pritchard #13 · Mike Pritchard · aggregate -1.62 3. Pickens #3 · Bruce Pickens · aggregate -1.94 20. Broussard #20 · Steve Broussard · aggregate -2.03 Broussard -2.0 145. Sadowski #145 · Troy Sadowski · aggregate -2.05 Sadowski -2.0 104. Smith #104 · Frankie Smith · aggregate -2.05 Smith -2.0 8. Whitfield #8 · Bob Whitfield · aggregate -2.09 Whitfield -2.1 110. Dimry #110 · Charles Dimry · aggregate -2.48 Dimry -2.5 9. Kennedy #9 · Lincoln Kennedy · aggregate -4.20 Kennedy -4.2 2. Casillas #2 · Tony Casillas · aggregate -4.53 Casillas -4.5 1. Bruce #1 · Aundray Bruce · aggregate -5.90 Bruce -5.9 5. Sanders #5 · Deion Sanders · aggregate -6.46 Sanders -6.5 33. Favre #33 · Brett Favre · aggregate -9.67 Favre -9.7 Incremental contribution by season -22 -20 -18 -16 -14 -12 -10 -8 -6 -4 -2 0 +2 +4 1986 · Floyd Dixon · incremental +0.50 1986 · Keith Williams · incremental -0.30 1986 · Tim Green · incremental -0.54 1986 · Tony Casillas · incremental -4.87 1987 · Tim Green · incremental +0.10 1987 · Michael Reid · incremental +0.14 1987 · Floyd Dixon · incremental +0.48 1987 · Chris Miller · incremental -0.38 1987 · Mark Mraz · incremental -0.45 1987 · Tony Casillas · incremental -0.45 1987 · Paul Kiser · incremental -0.94 1987 · Kenny Flowers · incremental -1.18 1987 · Ralph Van Dyke · incremental -1.38 1988 · Michael Haynes · incremental +0.06 1988 · Tim Green · incremental +0.10 1988 · Michael Reid · incremental +0.25 1988 · Houston Hoover · incremental +0.47 1988 · Floyd Dixon · incremental +0.52 1988 · George Thomas · incremental -0.02 1988 · Chris Miller · incremental -0.29 1988 · Marcus Cotton · incremental -0.80 1988 · Tony Casillas · incremental -0.95 1988 · Charles Dimry · incremental -1.14 1988 · Alex Higdon · incremental -1.38 1988 · Aundray Bruce · incremental -6.98 1989 · Tim Green · incremental +0.21 1989 · George Thomas · incremental +0.23 1989 · Michael Reid · incremental +0.25 1989 · Keith Jones · incremental +0.28 1989 · Floyd Dixon · incremental +0.38 1989 · Michael Haynes · incremental +0.40 1989 · Houston Hoover · incremental +0.70 1989 · Shawn Collins · incremental -0.18 1989 · Marcus Cotton · incremental -0.24 1989 · Chris Miller · incremental -0.36 1989 · Undra Johnson · incremental -0.44 1989 · Kenny Flowers · incremental -0.52 1989 · Charles Dimry · incremental -0.89 1989 · Deion Sanders · incremental -0.91 1989 · Tony Casillas · incremental -1.00 1989 · Troy Sadowski · incremental -1.04 1989 · Aundray Bruce · incremental -1.35 1989 · Ralph Norwood · incremental -1.89 1990 · Michael Reid · incremental +0.12 1990 · Tim Green · incremental +0.22 1990 · George Thomas · incremental +0.30 1990 · Michael Haynes · incremental +0.34 1990 · Floyd Dixon · incremental +0.35 1990 · Keith Jones · incremental +0.35 1990 · Houston Hoover · incremental +0.57 1990 · Shawn Collins · incremental -0.05 1990 · Oliver Barnett · incremental -0.07 1990 · Tony Casillas · incremental -0.19 1990 · Marcus Cotton · incremental -0.20 1990 · Chris Miller · incremental -0.30 1990 · Reggie Redding · incremental -0.36 1990 · Darion Conner · incremental -0.54 1990 · Mike Pringle · incremental -0.57 1990 · Aundray Bruce · incremental -0.75 1990 · Deion Sanders · incremental -1.22 1990 · Charles Dimry · incremental -1.74 1990 · Steve Broussard · incremental -1.96 1990 · Troy Sadowski · incremental -2.26 1991 · Shawn Collins · incremental +0.00 1991 · Michael Reid · incremental +0.03 1991 · Keith Jones · incremental +0.11 1991 · Tim Green · incremental +0.22 1991 · Floyd Dixon · incremental +0.22 1991 · Brian Mitchell · incremental +0.22 1991 · Erric Pegram · incremental +0.22 1991 · George Thomas · incremental +0.35 1991 · Michael Haynes · incremental +0.57 1991 · Houston Hoover · incremental +0.70 1991 · Moe Gardner · incremental +0.71 1991 · Oliver Barnett · incremental -0.09 1991 · Darion Conner · incremental -0.16 1991 · Bruce Pickens · incremental -0.26 1991 · Reggie Redding · incremental -0.36 1991 · Aundray Bruce · incremental -0.54 1991 · Mark Tucker · incremental -0.66 1991 · Steve Broussard · incremental -0.67 1991 · Chris Miller · incremental -0.85 1991 · James Goode · incremental -1.06 1991 · Mike Pritchard · incremental -1.39 1991 · Deion Sanders · incremental -2.26 1991 · Brett Favre · incremental -15.04 1992 · George Thomas · incremental +0.11 1992 · Tim Green · incremental +0.16 1992 · Erric Pegram · incremental +0.20 1992 · Michael Reid · incremental +0.24 1992 · Brian Mitchell · incremental +0.28 1992 · Keith Jones · incremental +0.33 1992 · Michael Haynes · incremental +0.50 1992 · Moe Gardner · incremental +0.70 1992 · Houston Hoover · incremental +0.75 1992 · Chuck Smith · incremental -0.04 1992 · Darion Conner · incremental -0.11 1992 · Terry Ray · incremental -0.11 1992 · Chris Miller · incremental -0.22 1992 · Oliver Barnett · incremental -0.23 1992 · Steve Broussard · incremental -0.44 1992 · Tim Paulk · incremental -0.60 1992 · Mike Pritchard · incremental -0.66 1992 · Howard Dinkins · incremental -0.75 1992 · Tony Smith · incremental -1.13 1992 · Bruce Pickens · incremental -1.50 1992 · Frankie Smith · incremental -3.29 1992 · Deion Sanders · incremental -3.46 1992 · Bob Whitfield · incremental -7.48 1993 · Mitch Lyons · incremental +0.06 1993 · Brian Mitchell · incremental +0.07 1993 · Tim Green · incremental +0.09 1993 · Darnell Walker · incremental +0.14 1993 · Harold Alexander · incremental +0.17 1993 · Roger Harper · incremental +0.21 1993 · Chuck Smith · incremental +0.24 1993 · Bob Whitfield · incremental +0.27 1993 · Michael Haynes · incremental +0.52 1993 · Erric Pegram · incremental +0.61 1993 · Moe Gardner · incremental +0.78 1993 · Chris Miller · incremental -0.06 1993 · Darion Conner · incremental -0.09 1993 · Ron George · incremental -0.09 1993 · Steve Broussard · incremental -0.19 1993 · Tony Smith · incremental -0.20 1993 · Mike Pritchard · incremental -0.57 1993 · Howard Dinkins · incremental -0.64 1993 · Bruce Pickens · incremental -0.94 1993 · Deion Sanders · incremental -3.34 1993 · Lincoln Kennedy · incremental -4.75 1994 · Ron George · incremental +0.03 1994 · Bert Emanuel · incremental +0.04 1994 · Mitch Lyons · incremental +0.06 1994 · Harold Alexander · incremental +0.10 1994 · Darnell Walker · incremental +0.19 1994 · Roger Harper · incremental +0.19 1994 · Erric Pegram · incremental +0.27 1994 · Bob Whitfield · incremental +0.27 1994 · Chuck Smith · incremental +0.44 1994 · Moe Gardner · incremental +0.82 1994 · Jamal Anderson · incremental -0.01 1994 · Tony Smith · incremental -0.02 1994 · Perry Klein · incremental -0.06 1994 · Anthony Phillips · incremental -0.08 1994 · Harrison Houston · incremental -0.57 1994 · Lincoln Kennedy · incremental -0.81 1994 · Mitch Davis · incremental -0.97 1994 · Alai Kalaniuvalu · incremental -1.20 1995 · Ron George · incremental +0.06 1995 · Mitch Lyons · incremental +0.08 1995 · John Burrough · incremental +0.14 1995 · Roell Preston · incremental +0.15 1995 · Darnell Walker · incremental +0.20 1995 · Roger Harper · incremental +0.26 1995 · Bob Whitfield · incremental +0.28 1995 · Jamal Anderson · incremental +0.29 1995 · Bert Emanuel · incremental +0.36 1995 · Chuck Smith · incremental +0.53 1995 · Moe Gardner · incremental +0.82 1995 · Anthony Phillips · incremental -0.14 1995 · Travis Hall · incremental -0.15 1995 · Devin Bush Sr. · incremental -0.46 1995 · Lorenzo Styles · incremental -0.87 1995 · Lincoln Kennedy · incremental -1.11 1995 · Ron Davis · incremental -1.17 1996 · Ron George · incremental +0.02 1996 · Mitch Lyons · incremental +0.12 1996 · John Burrough · incremental +0.12 1996 · Darnell Walker · incremental +0.21 1996 · Roell Preston · incremental +0.23 1996 · Bob Whitfield · incremental +0.27 1996 · Bert Emanuel · incremental +0.31 1996 · Travis Hall · incremental +0.48 1996 · Moe Gardner · incremental +0.49 1996 · Chuck Smith · incremental +0.51 1996 · Jamal Anderson · incremental +0.85 1996 · Anthony Phillips · incremental -0.16 1996 · Lorenzo Styles · incremental -0.30 1996 · Devin Bush Sr. · incremental -0.30 1997 · John Burrough · incremental +0.10 1997 · Michael Haynes · incremental +0.15 1997 · Bob Whitfield · incremental +0.27 1997 · Bert Emanuel · incremental +0.37 1997 · Travis Hall · incremental +0.61 1997 · Chuck Smith · incremental +0.68 1997 · Jamal Anderson · incremental +0.84 1997 · Devin Bush Sr. · incremental -0.31 1998 · Bob Whitfield · incremental +0.29 1998 · Travis Hall · incremental +0.54 1998 · Chuck Smith · incremental +0.65 1998 · Jamal Anderson · incremental +3.32 1998 · John Burrough · incremental -0.02 1998 · Devin Bush Sr. · incremental -0.06 1999 · Jamal Anderson · incremental +0.10 1999 · Bob Whitfield · incremental +0.27 1999 · Travis Hall · incremental +0.56 1999 · Chuck Smith · incremental +0.58 2000 · Bob Whitfield · incremental +0.25 2000 · Travis Hall · incremental +0.59 2000 · Jamal Anderson · incremental +0.86 2001 · Jamal Anderson · incremental +0.17 2001 · Bob Whitfield · incremental +0.28 2001 · Travis Hall · incremental +0.57 2002 · Travis Hall · incremental +0.19 2002 · Bob Whitfield · incremental +0.28 2003 · Bob Whitfield · incremental +0.13 2003 · Travis Hall · incremental +0.28 2004 · Travis Hall · incremental +0.22 Casillas -4.9 Bruce -7.0 Norwood -1.9 Broussard -2.0 Sadowski -2.3 Sanders -2.3 Favre -15.0 Smith -3.3 Sanders -3.5 Whitfield -7.5 Sanders -3.3 Kennedy -4.8 Anderson +3.3 1986 4 players 1987 9 players 1988 12 players 1989 18 players 1990 20 players 1991 23 players 1992 23 players 1993 21 players 1994 18 players 1995 17 players 1996 14 players 1997 8 players 1998 6 players 1999 4 players 2000 3 players 2001 3 players 2002 2 players 2003 2 players 2004 1 player
How much retained production did Frankie Smith return vs. his slot? Each mark below is one player's model value above slot. Light gray marks are slot-similar peers: DBs drafted within ±5 picks of Frankie Smith since 2010 (17 players).The score is the retained production/value bucket from the pick-residual model: on-team AV plus AV-rate quality, adjusted for draft slot, position, and era. Opportunity snaps and league honors are excluded.
-0.5 0 +0.5 +1 +1.5 +2 Model value above slot 104. Verner Alterraun Verner · model value +2.2 +2.2 104. Bennett Jakorian Bennett · model value +0.4 100. Searcy Da'Norris Searcy · model value +0.3 102. Breeland Bashaud Breeland · model value +0.2 105. Williams Duke Williams · model value +0.1 108. Carter Quinton Carter · model value +0.1 100. Molden Elijah Molden · model value 0 102. Thomas Ambry Thomas · model value 0 101. Melifonwu Ifeatu Melifonwu · model value 0 108. Jackson Khyree Jackson · model value -0.1 105. Lindley Trevard Lindley · model value -0.1 101. Bolden Omar Bolden · model value -0.1 105. Ringo Kelee Ringo · model value -0.2 99. Wright Nahshon Wright · model value -0.6 104. Taylor-Demerson Dadrion Taylor-Demerson · model value -0.6 101. Watkins Jaylen Watkins · model value -0.7 109. Cockrell Ross Cockrell · model value -0.8 104. Smith Frankie Smith · model value -0.8 -0.8 Frankie Smith
Cumulative value over time Year-by-year running totals since draft. Left axis = games started. Right axis = honors (Pro Bowl / AP1 / AP2). Pre-2013 picks have no games-started line because that comes from per-game snap counts (not available for older players). Honors extend back to 1980.
'92 '94 '96 '98 '00 0 1 2 3 4 0 1 Cumulative GS Honors count
Full-career season history (9 scored seasons) How to read this The current model groups outcomes into three buckets: opportunity (games, starts, snap-z), quality (on-team AV, AV/snap quality when available), and recognition (Pro Bowl, AP1).Season rows show full-career context across every team. The draft-credit cards above contain the team-specific totals used for GM accountability. Snap-z is position/year-normalized playing time; AV/snap is shown as AV per 1,000 snaps where snap evidence exists.AP2, full-career AV, HOF, and All-Decade are displayed as context only. They are not active outcomes in the current θ model.Pre-2013 playing-time rows may show "—" where weekly snap evidence is unavailable; AV/snap quality is snap-era only.