{ "schema_version": 1, "release_id": "2026-08-01-v30-deep-maturity", "publication_date": "2026-08-01", "source_commit": "c25bc86bbbbe439ae9d1ac22c59494bc98174e40", "publication_status": "published", "data_vintage": { "draft_year_start": 1980, "draft_year_end": 2025, "season_end": 2025, "picks": 10829, "unique_gms": 190, "gm_team_career_rows": 209, "source_pull_date": "2026-07-30" }, "headline": { "model_id": "v30_poly_indgm_scored_yos_avrate_gaussvol_mcmc_deep_i2500_w1000_ad095_td13", "model_label": "v30 multivariate brms/cmdstanr deep MCMC", "status": "production_headline", "entrypoints": [ "R/02_skill_model.R", "R/03_composite_and_leaderboard.R" ], "source_fit": "data/cache/skill_model_fit_v30_poly_indgm_scored_yos_avrate_gaussvol_mcmc_deep_i2500_w1000_ad095_td13.rds", "active_fit_alias": "data/cache/skill_model_fit.rds", "run_card": "docs/runs/2026-07-30-v30-deep-refit-post-av-repair.md", "validation": { "status": "sampler_diagnostics_passed_ppc_requires_methodological_review", "divergences": 0, "max_treedepth_hits": 0, "max_rhat": 1.008, "min_bulk_ess": 742.2, "posterior_predictive_refresh": { "status": "completed_with_material_ppc_flags_requires_methodological_review", "run_id": "2026-07-30-v30-validation", "entrypoint": "R/04d_production_posterior_predictive_checks.R", "artifact": "data/model_checks/2026-07-30-v30-validation/ppc-summary.json", "scope": "raw active-v30 likelihood replication; public maturity layer evaluated separately", "caveat": "Broad means replicate, but point mass at zero, impossible negative totals, dispersion, and upper tails show material lack of fit. This diagnostic does not quantify ranking movement under another family." } }, "public_score": "maturity-adjusted composite theta", "public_interval": "maturity-adjusted 95% credible interval", "maturity_layer": { "prior_player_years": 100, "player_year_cap": 8, "purpose": "shrink and widen low-evidence GM portfolios before publication" }, "artifact": { "path": "data/leaderboard.csv", "rows": 209, "unique_gms": 190, "md5": "5d3e0e995679fbbc2bc26d2acf096611", "required_columns": [ "gm", "raw_composite_mean", "raw_composite_sd", "raw_composite_q025", "raw_composite_q975", "raw_p_positive", "raw_n_blocks", "opportunity_block_mean", "production_block_mean", "recognition_block_mean", "opportunity_block_sd", "production_block_sd", "recognition_block_sd", "n_picks", "n_draft_classes", "first_draft_year", "last_draft_year", "cumulative_yos", "capped_player_years", "mean_yos", "recent_pick_share", "maturity_weight", "is_provisional", "composite_mean", "composite_sd", "composite_q025", "composite_q975", "p_positive", "pct", "verdict", "confidence", "gm_name", "team" ] } }, "support_artifacts": [ { "id": "v30-outcome-and-block-posteriors", "role": "headline_support", "entrypoint": "R/03_composite_and_leaderboard.R", "artifacts": [ { "path": "data/gm_outcome_posterior.csv", "rows": 1174, "md5": "9d67c5d5c5924e627a5ce8900e70764c", "required_columns": [ "gm", "outcome", "block", "theta_mean", "theta_sd", "theta_q025", "theta_q975" ] }, { "path": "data/gm_block_posterior.csv", "rows": 570, "md5": "f60ff43c89e9003117c7fcc4df138511", "required_columns": [ "gm", "block", "theta_mean", "theta_sd", "theta_q025", "theta_q975" ] } ] }, { "id": "v30-per-pick-residuals-fast-support", "role": "support_only_not_headline_ranking", "entrypoint": "R/05_per_pick_residuals.R", "source_fit": "active v30 deep fit alias (data/cache/skill_model_fit.rds)", "caveat": "Per-pick residuals are explanatory diagnostics, not a second GM rating or a substitute for the deep headline posterior.", "artifacts": [ { "path": "data/pick_residuals_wide.csv", "rows": 10829, "md5": "d2fd5d1bcc24a0dbd34da14c91580bcc", "required_columns": [ "gm_id", "draft_year", "pick_overall", "player_name", "pos_model", "pos_off_def", "rz_gp", "rz_cgs", "rz_pb", "rz_ap", "rz_snaps", "rz_av", "rz_av_rate", "rz_opportunity", "rz_production", "rz_recognition", "total_z", "n_blocks" ] }, { "path": "data/pick_contributions.csv", "rows": 10829, "md5": "7c0a3fb949846619e0af33a5999bd99f", "required_columns": [ ".row", "gm_id", "draft_year", "pick_overall", "player_name", "pos_model", "pos_off_def", "draft_team_str", "total_residual_z", "n_outcomes", "n_blocks" ] } ] }, { "id": "v30-record-vs-verdict-projection", "role": "support_only_not_headline_ranking", "entrypoint": "R/03b_record_vs_verdict.R", "caveat": "The record-only estimate is a descriptive projection of raw draft outcomes ('his record alone') used to explain partial pooling, era/capital adjustment, and the maturity discount. It is a support view, never a score, rating, index, ranking, or second leaderboard.", "artifacts": [ { "path": "data/gm_record_vs_verdict.csv", "rows": 209, "md5": "40612285e87968009f27cb6d39aa68a1", "required_columns": [ "gm", "gm_name", "team", "record_only_estimate", "raw_composite_mean", "composite_mean", "composite_q025", "composite_q975", "pull_pooling", "pull_maturity", "divergence_rz", "is_shrinkage_flagged", "n_picks", "maturity_weight", "is_provisional" ] }, { "path": "data/gm_record_vs_verdict_meta.json", "items": 1, "md5": "81f09e2671aa80c4225eda8e77e03953", "json_schema": { "type": "array", "items": { "type": "object", "required": [ "schema_version", "artifact", "role", "feature_spec", "feature_definitions", "calibration", "selection_rule", "source_leaderboard" ], "properties": { "schema_version": { "type": "number" }, "artifact": { "type": "string" }, "role": { "type": "string" }, "feature_spec": { "type": "string" }, "feature_definitions": { "type": "object" }, "calibration": { "type": "object" }, "selection_rule": { "type": "object" }, "source_leaderboard": { "type": "object" } } } } } ] }, { "id": "v30-incremental-trajectory", "role": "support_only_trajectory_view", "entrypoint": "R/06_incremental_theta.R", "version": "v30_poly_indgm_scored_yos_avrate_gaussvol_mcmc snapshots 1981-2025", "caveat": "Trajectory estimates show how evidence accumulated at each season-end snapshot; they are not the current maturity-adjusted headline ranking.", "artifacts": [ { "path": "data/theta_trajectory.csv", "rows": 4671, "md5": "6cf6be3e2ba2c68024ec5fa029e961e9", "required_columns": [ "gm_id", "theta_mean", "theta_sd", "theta_q025", "theta_q975", "p_positive", "year", "n_picks_through_T", "cum_yos_through_T", "gm_name" ] } ] }, { "id": "site-context-data-2025", "role": "site_context", "entrypoints": [ "R/00_pull_data.R", "R/01b_build_player_seasons.R", "R/00d_pull_records.R" ], "artifacts": [ { "path": "data/picks_summary.csv", "rows": 10829, "md5": "3d406396ea998eed6a91323569da20a7", "required_columns": [ "pfr_id", "draft_year", "round", "pick_overall", "draft_team", "player_name", "position_draft", "pos_model", "side", "college", "age_draft", "last_season", "career_pb_total", "career_ap_total", "ap2_on_team", "career_av_full", "career_pb_anywhere", "career_ap1_anywhere", "career_ap2_anywhere", "career_games_played_full", "career_games_started_full", "career_length_full", "career_length_observed", "career_snaps_on_team", "career_snap_z_on_team", "n_snap_z_seasons", "career_av_on_team", "n_av_seasons_on_team", "career_av_any_team_unweighted", "n_av_seasons_any_team", "career_av_credit_to_drafting_team", "departure_type", "departure_season", "departure_team", "acquiring_team", "career_pb_credit_to_drafting_team", "career_ap1_credit_to_drafting_team", "av_rate_snaps_on_team", "av_rate_av_on_team", "av_rate_quality_weight_on_team", "av_rate_quality_z_on_team", "av_rate_quality_z_on_team_y1", "av_rate_quality_z_on_team_y2", "av_rate_quality_z_on_team_y3", "av_rate_quality_z_on_team_y4", "is_hof_inductee", "n_all_decade_selections", "yos", "yos_scored", "career_mvp_wins", "career_opoy_wins", "career_dpoy_wins", "career_oroy_wins", "career_droy_wins", "career_mvp_seasons_w_votes", "career_opoy_seasons_w_votes", "career_dpoy_seasons_w_votes", "career_oroy_seasons_w_votes", "career_droy_seasons_w_votes" ] }, { "path": "data/player_seasons.csv", "rows": 67985, "md5": "df02ea292439e2cc14698d7c73fea624", "required_columns": [ "pfr_id", "season", "team", "games_played_in_season", "games_started_in_season", "off_snaps_in_season", "def_snaps_in_season", "st_snaps_in_season", "snaps_in_season", "snap_z_in_season", "av_in_season", "has_snap_evidence", "has_pfr_playing_time", "was_pb_in_season", "was_ap1_in_season", "was_ap2_in_season" ] }, { "path": "data/gm_tenures.csv", "rows": 213, "md5": "ab0b4a46b49a75d85f3078dbe42ede90", "required_columns": [ "gm_id", "gm_name", "team", "first_draft_year", "last_draft_year", "notes" ] }, { "path": "data/player_departure_overrides.csv", "rows": 16, "md5": "850d219030f97a70c16a2a9669cd61cd", "required_columns": [ "draft_pick_id", "pfr_id", "departure_type", "departure_season", "departure_team", "acquiring_team", "later_value_credit", "proves_zero_on_team", "source_url", "note" ] }, { "path": "data/team_records.csv", "rows": 1401, "md5": "99f9ada2634aca0f8a531e4e58da9165", "required_columns": [ "team", "season", "wins", "losses", "ties", "made_playoffs", "playoff_exit" ] } ] }, { "id": "independent-player-hof-trajectory-forecast", "role": "independent_player_hof_forecast_not_gm_headline", "entrypoint": "R/12_hof_trajectory_forecast.R", "caveat": "This player Hall of Fame forecast is an independent publication surface. It neither contributes to nor replaces the v30 GM headline ranking.", "artifacts": [ { "path": "data/hof_trajectory_leaderboard.csv", "rows": 1398, "md5": "9da776a1c15f807c559a9c17916d679c", "required_columns": [ "rank_current_resume", "rank_trajectory", "pfr_id", "player_name", "current_team", "roster_status", "roster_status_description", "roster_week", "draft_year", "draft_team", "pick_overall", "position_draft", "pos_family", "yos", "current_resume_hof_likelihood", "current_resume_likelihood_pct", "current_resume_band", "trajectory_hof_likelihood", "trajectory_likelihood_pct", "trajectory_band", "trajectory_hof_p10", "trajectory_hof_p50", "trajectory_hof_p90", "sim_final_av_p10", "sim_final_av_p50", "sim_final_av_p90", "sim_final_pb_p10", "sim_final_pb_p50", "sim_final_pb_p90", "sim_final_ap1_p10", "sim_final_ap1_p50", "sim_final_ap1_p90", "sim_final_awards_p10", "sim_final_awards_p50", "sim_final_awards_p90", "tail_breakout_probability", "collapse_probability", "retirement_within_2y_probability", "career_av_full", "career_pb_anywhere", "career_ap1_anywhere", "career_mvp_wins", "career_opoy_wins", "career_dpoy_wins", "career_games_played_full", "career_games_started_full", "pass_yards", "pass_tds", "rush_yards", "rush_tds", "receptions", "rec_yards", "rec_tds", "def_sacks", "def_ints", "def_solo_tackles", "model_current_season", "model_active_statuses", "model_train_n", "model_train_hof_n", "trajectory_n_sim", "trajectory_model_version", "trajectory_cv_brier", "trajectory_cv_logloss", "trajectory_interval_coverage_80", "trajectory_tail_calibration_error" ] } ] }, { "id": "v30-residual-trend-diagnostics", "role": "diagnostic_only_not_headline_ranking", "entrypoint": "R/09_trend_tests.R", "caveat": "Trend tests diagnose residual structure for the published inputs; they are not a GM rating or an independent headline model.", "artifacts": [ { "path": "data/diagnostics/trend_tests.json", "items": 352, "md5": "d32f5bd24d70fdcdaf11b3467b24df85", "json_schema": { "type": "array", "items": { "type": "object", "required": [ "outcome", "dim", "kind", "slope", "std_err", "r_squared", "f_stat", "eta_sq", "n_levels", "p_value", "n", "status" ], "properties": { "outcome": { "type": "string" }, "dim": { "type": "string" }, "kind": { "type": "string" }, "slope": { "type": [ "number", "null" ] }, "std_err": { "type": [ "number", "null" ] }, "r_squared": { "type": [ "number", "null" ] }, "f_stat": { "type": [ "number", "null" ] }, "eta_sq": { "type": [ "number", "null" ] }, "n_levels": { "type": [ "number", "null" ] }, "p_value": { "type": [ "number", "null" ] }, "n": { "type": "number" }, "status": { "type": "string" } } } } } ] }, { "id": "v30-active-model-checks-2026-07-30", "role": "diagnostic_only_not_headline_ranking", "run_id": "2026-07-30-v30-validation", "status": "completed_with_material_ppc_flags_requires_methodological_review", "source_fit": "data/cache/skill_model_fit_v30_poly_indgm_scored_yos_avrate_gaussvol_mcmc_deep_i2500_w1000_ad095_td13.rds", "run_card": "docs/runs/2026-07-30-v30-deep-refit-post-av-repair.md", "entrypoints": [ "R/04d_production_posterior_predictive_checks.R", "R/04e_public_composite_validation.R" ], "caveat": "These artifacts diagnose the raw active-v30 likelihood, reconstruct and stress-test the public maturity layer, and screen temporal stability against later support-route estimates. They do not establish empirical coverage, authorize a headline refit, or change the public release status.", "artifacts": [ { "path": "data/model_checks/2026-07-30-v30-validation/ppc-summary.json", "items": 1, "md5": "ba8587807f75ca6bfc2f2a61bc8d12ea", "json_schema": { "type": "array", "items": { "type": "object", "required": [ "schema_version", "check_type", "run_id", "generated_at_utc", "status", "scope", "source_fit", "draw_budget", "subset_mapping", "response_summary", "flags", "artifact_references", "compatibility_notes" ], "properties": { "schema_version": { "type": "number" }, "check_type": { "type": "string" }, "run_id": { "type": "string" }, "generated_at_utc": { "type": "string" }, "status": { "type": "string" }, "scope": { "type": "object" }, "source_fit": { "type": "object" }, "draw_budget": { "type": "object" }, "subset_mapping": { "type": "object" }, "response_summary": { "type": "object" }, "flags": { "type": "object" }, "artifact_references": { "type": "object" }, "compatibility_notes": { "type": "array" } } } } }, { "path": "data/model_checks/2026-07-30-v30-validation/posterior-predictive-outcome-summary.csv", "rows": 56, "md5": "1f87970ccc562bd1ee00e384fd36513c", "required_columns": [ "response", "outcome_column", "family", "n_observed", "metric", "rep_q025", "rep_q10", "rep_median", "rep_q90", "rep_q975", "observed", "observed_inside_95" ] }, { "path": "data/model_checks/2026-07-30-v30-validation/posterior-predictive-flags.csv", "rows": 158, "md5": "4b715f0a89744fd5f1cf2bbe0a4a3758", "required_columns": [ "scope", "response", "dimension", "level", "n_group", "metric", "observed", "rep_q025", "rep_q975" ] }, { "path": "data/model_checks/2026-07-30-v30-validation/public-composite-summary.json", "items": 1, "md5": "fd0951e15dd732fd970667a51c1cc242", "json_schema": { "type": "array", "items": { "type": "object", "required": [ "run_id", "analysis_date", "model_route", "public_interval_label", "analysis_type", "trajectory_compatibility", "trajectory_target", "headline_gm_team_career_rows", "unique_gms", "trajectory_snapshot_year_min", "trajectory_snapshot_year_max", "temporal_horizon_years", "temporal_pair_count", "temporal_unique_gms", "raw_later_point_inside_earlier_interval_rate", "public_later_point_inside_earlier_interval_rate", "raw_mean_absolute_change_to_later_raw", "public_mean_absolute_change_to_later_raw", "baseline_reconstruction_max_abs_public_mean_error", "baseline_reconstruction_max_abs_public_sd_error", "baseline_reconstruction_max_abs_interval_error", "maturity_sensitivity_scenario_count", "maturity_sensitivity_point_ranking_transform_count", "maturity_sensitivity_min_spearman", "maturity_sensitivity_min_top_20_overlap_rate", "maturity_sensitivity_min_bottom_20_overlap_rate", "maturity_sensitivity_max_absolute_rank_shift", "maturity_sensitivity_interval_width_min", "maturity_sensitivity_interval_width_max", "final_trajectory_vs_headline_raw_spearman", "final_trajectory_vs_headline_mean_absolute_difference" ], "properties": { "run_id": { "type": "string" }, "analysis_date": { "type": "string" }, "model_route": { "type": "string" }, "public_interval_label": { "type": "string" }, "analysis_type": { "type": "string" }, "trajectory_compatibility": { "type": "string" }, "trajectory_target": { "type": "string" }, "headline_gm_team_career_rows": { "type": "number" }, "unique_gms": { "type": "number" }, "temporal_pair_count": { "type": "number" }, "temporal_unique_gms": { "type": "number" } } } } }, { "path": "data/model_checks/2026-07-30-v30-validation/public-composite-temporal-stability-summary.csv", "rows": 10, "md5": "6283c8f1ef0c852a1476e3fd6c9710d8", "required_columns": [ "comparison_layer", "evidence_band", "screen_type", "target_role", "n_pairs", "n_unique_gms", "earlier_year_min", "earlier_year_max", "mean_signed_change_to_later_raw", "mean_absolute_change_to_later_raw", "median_absolute_change_to_later_raw", "p90_absolute_change_to_later_raw", "rmse_to_later_raw", "mean_earlier_interval_width", "later_raw_point_inside_earlier_interval_rate", "point_sign_agreement_rate", "earlier_later_point_spearman" ] }, { "path": "data/model_checks/2026-07-30-v30-validation/public-composite-maturity-sensitivity-summary.csv", "rows": 36, "md5": "82826a01b0b7840e18a17d352840e148", "required_columns": [ "scenario_id", "is_baseline", "maturity_player_year_cap", "maturity_prior_player_years", "maturity_prior_sd", "n_unique_gms", "spearman_rank_correlation", "mean_absolute_rank_shift", "median_absolute_rank_shift", "max_absolute_rank_shift", "n_rank_improved", "n_rank_worsened", "n_rank_unchanged", "top_20_n", "top_20_overlap_n", "top_20_overlap_rate", "bottom_20_n", "bottom_20_overlap_n", "bottom_20_overlap_rate", "mean_absolute_public_mean_change", "max_absolute_public_mean_change", "mean_interval_width", "median_interval_width", "n_interval_above_zero", "n_interval_below_zero", "n_interval_overlaps_zero", "n_interval_direction_changed" ] }, { "path": "data/model_checks/2026-07-30-v30-validation/run-metadata.json", "items": 1, "md5": "a331d006c36c04522881f693641ef243", "json_schema": { "type": "array", "items": { "type": "object", "required": [ "schema_version", "run_id", "model", "release", "run", "scope", "reproduction", "compatibility", "claim_limits" ], "properties": { "schema_version": { "type": "number" }, "run_id": { "type": "string" }, "model": { "type": "object" }, "release": { "type": "object" }, "run": { "type": "object" }, "scope": { "type": "object" }, "reproduction": { "type": "object" }, "compatibility": { "type": "object" }, "claim_limits": { "type": "array" } } } } }, { "path": "data/model_checks/2026-07-30-v30-validation/archive.json", "items": 1, "md5": "b4d2550cce37b9a71ea60f73a6a64c86", "json_schema": { "type": "array", "items": { "type": "object", "required": [ "schema_version", "run_id", "model", "release", "run", "scope", "reproduction", "compatibility", "claim_limits", "source_fit", "artifacts" ], "properties": { "schema_version": { "type": "number" }, "run_id": { "type": "string" }, "model": { "type": "object" }, "release": { "type": "object" }, "run": { "type": "object" }, "scope": { "type": "object" }, "reproduction": { "type": "object" }, "compatibility": { "type": "object" }, "claim_limits": { "type": "array" }, "source_fit": { "type": "object" }, "artifacts": { "type": "array" } } } } } ] } ], "comparison_models": [ { "id": "latent_stan_unified_theta", "entrypoint": "R/02e_latent_skill_model.R", "status": "experimental_comparison", "publication_rule": "Must not replace data/leaderboard.csv without a new reviewed release manifest and run card." } ] }