← 2010 DRAFT PLAYER PROFILE R1 · #15 OVERALL · DE

Jason Pierre-Paul

Drafted by NYG · GM Jerry Reese · South Florida

All NFL teams

Full-career context

These totals follow Jason Pierre-Paul across every NFL team. Draft credit is separated below for each team that selected him.

Games played185
Games started150
Weighted career AV74
Pro Bowls3
AP1 All-Pro1
Career seasons16

Accountability by draft event

What each drafting team received

2010 · Round 1 · #15

NYG draft credit

GM Jerry Reese

Team games111
Team starts85
On-team AV57
On-team PB / AP12 / 1
Terrible-3.42 contribution76th of 78 picks for this GM

Games: direct team-season record. Starts: direct team-season record.

Long-career hit

Jason Pierre-Paul became a 16-season, 185-game NFL player after going #15. The retained-value model still ranks him 76th of 78 for Jerry Reese because NYG only got 111 of those games.

His retained-value contribution score (opportunity plus quality plus recognition, with related outcomes collapsed inside each bucket) is -3.42. This is a per-pick accountability metric, separate from Jerry Reese's leaderboard composite θ.

Full-career context prevents this from being labeled as a bad talent pick: the negative model score is about retained team value, not whether the draft identified an NFL-caliber player.

The walkthrough below shows which bucket carried the pick: playing time, value quality, or league honors.

Opportunity
Did he earn the field?
Games played
111
on drafting team · 185 full-career
Games started
85
on drafting team · 150 full-career
Snap-z
6.3
5 modeled seasons
Quality
Was that time valuable?
On-team AV
57
modeled; full weighted AV 74
AV / 1k snaps
7.4
4,050 snaps in rate base
AV-rate z
+0.1
position-year adjusted quality
Recognition
Did the league notice?
Pro Bowls
2
3 full-career
AP1 All-Pro
1 AP1
all on drafting team · AP2 context 0
All-Decade
0
context only

Did this pick move Jerry Reese's grade?

The first chart removes the time axis: every Jerry Reese pick is sorted by retained contribution across opportunity, quality, and recognition. Jason Pierre-Paul totals -3.42. The second chart breaks that same contribution into the seasons when the evidence arrived. Opportunity and quality can move separately, which keeps high-snap, low-AV profiles from looking cleaner than they are.

Aggregate contribution by player

-4-3-2-10+1+2+333. Collins#33 · Landon Collins · aggregate +3.42Collins +3.4224. Johnson#224 · Michael Johnson · aggregate +1.63250. Bradshaw#250 · Ahmad Bradshaw · aggregate +1.54153. Boss#153 · Kevin Boss · aggregate +1.43202. Williams#202 · Jacquian Williams · aggregate +1.4263. Randle#63 · Rueben Randle · aggregate +1.28116. DeOssie#116 · Zak DeOssie · aggregate +1.1051. Smith#51 · Steve Smith · aggregate +1.00239. Kuhn#239 · Markus Kuhn · aggregate +0.9863. Thomas#63 · Terrell Thomas · aggregate +0.9595. Manningham#95 · Mario Manningham · aggregate +0.77165. Goff#165 · Jonathan Goff · aggregate +0.62221. Dodge#221 · Matt Dodge · aggregate +0.53140. Gallman#140 · Wayne Gallman · aggregate +0.49129. Brown#129 · Andre Brown · aggregate +0.45221. Scott#221 · Da'Rel Scott · aggregate +0.3994. Hosley#94 · Jayron Hosley · aggregate +0.2729. Nicks#29 · Hakeem Nicks · aggregate +0.22100. Beckum#100 · Travis Beckum · aggregate +0.2143. Richburg#43 · Weston Richburg · aggregate +0.19198. Woodson#198 · Andre Woodson · aggregate +0.18174. Kennard#174 · Devon Kennard · aggregate +0.13198. Sash#198 · Tyler Sash · aggregate +0.04117. Brewer#117 · James Brewer · aggregate +0.00151. Bomar#151 · Rhett Bomar · aggregate -0.01184. Adams#184 · Jerell Adams · aggregate -0.03184. Tracy#184 · Adrian Tracy · aggregate -0.03127. Robinson#127 · Adrien Robinson · aggregate -0.04253. Cox#253 · Michael Cox · aggregate -0.05152. Berhe#152 · Nat Berhe · aggregate -0.07186. Davis#186 · Geremy Davis · aggregate -0.0781. Alford#81 · Jay Alford · aggregate -0.08109. Goodson#109 · B.J. Goodson · aggregate -0.08113. Williams#113 · Andre Williams · aggregate -0.0983. Jernigan#83 · Jerrel Jernigan · aggregate -0.10238. Woodson#238 · Stoney Woodson · aggregate -0.11189. Koets#189 · Adam Koets · aggregate -0.12185. Jones#185 · Greg Jones · aggregate -0.1260. Beatty#60 · Will Beatty · aggregate -0.12199. Henderson#199 · Robert Henderson · aggregate -0.1785. Barden#85 · Ramses Barden · aggregate -0.1955. Tomlinson#55 · Dalvin Tomlinson · aggregate -0.20200. Wright#200 · DeAndre Wright · aggregate -0.21131. Mosley#131 · Brandon Mosley · aggregate -0.22149. Perkins#149 · Paul Perkins · aggregate -0.23147. Petrus#147 · Mitch Petrus · aggregate -0.2974. Bromley#74 · Jay Bromley · aggregate -0.31110. Nassib#110 · Ryan Nassib · aggregate -0.31167. Moss#167 · Avery Moss · aggregate -0.4020. Ross#20 · Aaron Ross · aggregate -0.44123. Kehl#123 · Bryan Kehl · aggregate -0.45152. Taylor#152 · Cooper Taylor · aggregate -0.4771. Thompson#71 · Darian Thompson · aggregate -0.47201. McCants#201 · Matt McCants · aggregate -0.54225. Herman#225 · Eric Herman · aggregate -0.5431. Phillips#31 · Kenny Phillips · aggregate -0.69115. Dillard#115 · Phillip Dillard · aggregate -0.6923. Engram#23 · Evan Engram · aggregate -0.74200. Bisnowaty#200 · Adam Bisnowaty · aggregate -0.8032. Wilson#32 · David Wilson · aggregate -0.8476. Jones#76 · Chad Jones · aggregate -0.84144. Thompson#144 · Mykkele Thompson · aggregate -0.8552. Austin#52 · Marvin Austin · aggregate -0.9645. Sintim#45 · Clint Sintim · aggregate -0.9687. Webb#87 · Davis Webb · aggregate -1.1074. Odighizuwa#74 · Owamagbe Odighizuwa · aggregate -1.1240. Shepard#40 · Sterling Shepard · aggregate -1.30187. Jackson#187 · Bennett Jackson · aggregate -1.3081. Moore#81 · Damontre Moore · aggregate -1.5519. Amukamara#19 · Prince Amukamara · aggregate -1.599. Flowers#9 · Ereck Flowers · aggregate -1.69226. Hart#226 · Bobby Hart · aggregate -1.7812. Jr.#12 · Odell Beckham Jr. · aggregate -2.00Jr. -2.049. Hankins#49 · Johnathan Hankins · aggregate -2.49Hankins -2.519. Pugh#19 · Justin Pugh · aggregate -3.05Pugh -3.015. Pierre-Paul#15 · Jason Pierre-Paul · aggregate -3.42Pierre-Paul -3.446. Joseph#46 · Linval Joseph · aggregate -3.63Joseph -3.610. Apple#10 · Eli Apple · aggregate -4.61Apple -4.6

Incremental contribution by season

-18-16-14-12-10-8-6-4-20+2+4+62007 · Jay Alford · incremental +0.032007 · Ahmad Bradshaw · incremental +0.042007 · Kevin Boss · incremental +0.202007 · Michael Johnson · incremental +0.552007 · Steve Smith · incremental -0.002007 · Adam Koets · incremental -0.022007 · Aaron Ross · incremental -0.832007 · Zak DeOssie · incremental -0.922008 · Aaron Ross · incremental +0.012008 · Jonathan Goff · incremental +0.032008 · Steve Smith · incremental +0.172008 · Andre Woodson · incremental +0.222008 · Ahmad Bradshaw · incremental +0.242008 · Kevin Boss · incremental +0.662008 · Zak DeOssie · incremental +0.892008 · Michael Johnson · incremental +1.072008 · Terrell Thomas · incremental +1.092008 · Adam Koets · incremental -0.012008 · Mario Manningham · incremental -0.012008 · Jay Alford · incremental -0.172008 · Robert Henderson · incremental -0.362008 · Bryan Kehl · incremental -0.482008 · Kenny Phillips · incremental -0.532009 · Travis Beckum · incremental +0.012009 · Aaron Ross · incremental +0.022009 · Zak DeOssie · incremental +0.172009 · Jonathan Goff · incremental +0.292009 · Ahmad Bradshaw · incremental +0.352009 · Mario Manningham · incremental +0.402009 · Terrell Thomas · incremental +0.462009 · Kevin Boss · incremental +0.702009 · Michael Johnson · incremental +0.902009 · Andre Brown · incremental +0.922009 · Steve Smith · incremental +1.322009 · Adam Koets · incremental -0.022009 · Kenny Phillips · incremental -0.032009 · Ramses Barden · incremental -0.042009 · Rhett Bomar · incremental -0.072009 · Bryan Kehl · incremental -0.202009 · Stoney Woodson · incremental -0.292009 · DeAndre Wright · incremental -0.442009 · Clint Sintim · incremental -0.462009 · Hakeem Nicks · incremental -0.892009 · Will Beatty · incremental -0.962010 · Ramses Barden · incremental +0.002010 · Michael Johnson · incremental +0.042010 · Aaron Ross · incremental +0.062010 · Will Beatty · incremental +0.082010 · Travis Beckum · incremental +0.112010 · Steve Smith · incremental +0.122010 · Hakeem Nicks · incremental +0.402010 · Mario Manningham · incremental +0.412010 · Terrell Thomas · incremental +0.482010 · Ahmad Bradshaw · incremental +0.532010 · Jonathan Goff · incremental +0.662010 · Kevin Boss · incremental +0.662010 · Matt Dodge · incremental +0.672010 · Zak DeOssie · incremental +0.892010 · Bryan Kehl · incremental -0.002010 · Adrian Tracy · incremental -0.082010 · Mitch Petrus · incremental -0.132010 · Adam Koets · incremental -0.192010 · Kenny Phillips · incremental -0.202010 · Clint Sintim · incremental -1.012010 · Phillip Dillard · incremental -1.122010 · Chad Jones · incremental -1.412010 · Jason Pierre-Paul · incremental -2.032010 · Linval Joseph · incremental -4.312011 · Ramses Barden · incremental +0.002011 · Tyler Sash · incremental +0.012011 · Aaron Ross · incremental +0.022011 · Zak DeOssie · incremental +0.142011 · Will Beatty · incremental +0.162011 · Travis Beckum · incremental +0.182011 · Jerrel Jernigan · incremental +0.222011 · Mario Manningham · incremental +0.312011 · Ahmad Bradshaw · incremental +0.392011 · James Brewer · incremental +0.452011 · Hakeem Nicks · incremental +0.472011 · Da'Rel Scott · incremental +1.132011 · Jacquian Williams · incremental +2.432011 · Kenny Phillips · incremental -0.182011 · Greg Jones · incremental -0.222011 · Mitch Petrus · incremental -0.362011 · Marvin Austin · incremental -0.572011 · Linval Joseph · incremental -1.472011 · Prince Amukamara · incremental -2.112011 · Jason Pierre-Paul · incremental -2.522012 · Da'Rel Scott · incremental +0.022012 · Jerrel Jernigan · incremental +0.032012 · Tyler Sash · incremental +0.042012 · Travis Beckum · incremental +0.042012 · Andre Brown · incremental +0.052012 · Zak DeOssie · incremental +0.142012 · Will Beatty · incremental +0.252012 · Adrien Robinson · incremental +0.252012 · Jacquian Williams · incremental +0.262012 · Hakeem Nicks · incremental +0.372012 · Jayron Hosley · incremental +0.422012 · Ahmad Bradshaw · incremental +0.542012 · Markus Kuhn · incremental +1.752012 · Rueben Randle · incremental +1.992012 · Adrian Tracy · incremental -0.012012 · James Brewer · incremental -0.022012 · Brandon Mosley · incremental -0.042012 · Kenny Phillips · incremental -0.072012 · Ramses Barden · incremental -0.302012 · Prince Amukamara · incremental -0.342012 · Matt McCants · incremental -0.922012 · Marvin Austin · incremental -0.982012 · David Wilson · incremental -1.392012 · Jason Pierre-Paul · incremental -1.562012 · Linval Joseph · incremental -1.582013 · Aaron Ross · incremental +0.012013 · Da'Rel Scott · incremental +0.052013 · Jayron Hosley · incremental +0.122013 · Zak DeOssie · incremental +0.122013 · Markus Kuhn · incremental +0.122013 · Andre Brown · incremental +0.122013 · Will Beatty · incremental +0.242013 · Terrell Thomas · incremental +0.322013 · Hakeem Nicks · incremental +0.382013 · Rueben Randle · incremental +0.392013 · Jacquian Williams · incremental +0.632013 · Michael Cox · incremental -0.012013 · Adrien Robinson · incremental -0.012013 · David Wilson · incremental -0.202013 · Jason Pierre-Paul · incremental -0.232013 · James Brewer · incremental -0.272013 · Jerrel Jernigan · incremental -0.292013 · Ryan Nassib · incremental -0.302013 · Brandon Mosley · incremental -0.342013 · Prince Amukamara · incremental -0.512013 · Cooper Taylor · incremental -0.582013 · Eric Herman · incremental -0.942013 · Linval Joseph · incremental -1.442013 · Damontre Moore · incremental -1.502013 · Johnathan Hankins · incremental -1.922013 · Justin Pugh · incremental -4.032014 · Michael Cox · incremental +0.012014 · Jayron Hosley · incremental +0.072014 · Brandon Mosley · incremental +0.122014 · Zak DeOssie · incremental +0.142014 · Weston Richburg · incremental +0.192014 · Will Beatty · incremental +0.252014 · Markus Kuhn · incremental +0.342014 · Jacquian Williams · incremental +0.412014 · Jay Bromley · incremental +0.472014 · Rueben Randle · incremental +0.572014 · Andre Williams · incremental +2.452014 · James Brewer · incremental -0.032014 · Nat Berhe · incremental -0.052014 · Eric Herman · incremental -0.082014 · Devon Kennard · incremental -0.112014 · Jerrel Jernigan · incremental -0.122014 · Cooper Taylor · incremental -0.132014 · Ryan Nassib · incremental -0.222014 · Prince Amukamara · incremental -0.232014 · Jason Pierre-Paul · incremental -0.402014 · Adrien Robinson · incremental -0.412014 · Justin Pugh · incremental -0.642014 · Damontre Moore · incremental -1.082014 · Johnathan Hankins · incremental -1.512014 · Odell Beckham Jr. · incremental -1.942014 · Bennett Jackson · incremental -2.152015 · Nat Berhe · incremental +0.012015 · Hakeem Nicks · incremental +0.062015 · Devon Kennard · incremental +0.082015 · Geremy Davis · incremental +0.122015 · Zak DeOssie · incremental +0.122015 · Jayron Hosley · incremental +0.192015 · Weston Richburg · incremental +0.402015 · Markus Kuhn · incremental +0.422015 · Rueben Randle · incremental +0.542015 · Landon Collins · incremental +0.592015 · Andre Williams · incremental +0.892015 · Michael Cox · incremental -0.012015 · Eric Herman · incremental -0.092015 · Ryan Nassib · incremental -0.102015 · Jason Pierre-Paul · incremental -0.182015 · Bennett Jackson · incremental -0.222015 · Cooper Taylor · incremental -0.272015 · Odell Beckham Jr. · incremental -0.332015 · Prince Amukamara · incremental -0.332015 · Justin Pugh · incremental -0.672015 · Johnathan Hankins · incremental -0.692015 · Mykkele Thompson · incremental -0.712015 · Jay Bromley · incremental -0.712015 · Owamagbe Odighizuwa · incremental -0.842015 · Damontre Moore · incremental -1.022015 · Bobby Hart · incremental -1.762015 · Ereck Flowers · incremental -1.822016 · Will Beatty · incremental +0.042016 · Jerell Adams · incremental +0.062016 · Zak DeOssie · incremental +0.142016 · Devon Kennard · incremental +0.252016 · Jay Bromley · incremental +0.262016 · Weston Richburg · incremental +0.422016 · Landon Collins · incremental +3.532016 · Michael Cox · incremental -0.012016 · Nat Berhe · incremental -0.022016 · Ryan Nassib · incremental -0.062016 · Eric Herman · incremental -0.082016 · Cooper Taylor · incremental -0.132016 · Bennett Jackson · incremental -0.222016 · Jason Pierre-Paul · incremental -0.302016 · Darian Thompson · incremental -0.372016 · Justin Pugh · incremental -0.422016 · Paul Perkins · incremental -0.432016 · B.J. Goodson · incremental -0.642016 · Mykkele Thompson · incremental -0.832016 · Ereck Flowers · incremental -0.852016 · Owamagbe Odighizuwa · incremental -1.252016 · Bobby Hart · incremental -1.312016 · Johnathan Hankins · incremental -1.662016 · Odell Beckham Jr. · incremental -2.012016 · Sterling Shepard · incremental -2.072016 · Eli Apple · incremental -7.142017 · Zak DeOssie · incremental +0.142017 · Devon Kennard · incremental +0.242017 · Wayne Gallman · incremental +0.852017 · Landon Collins · incremental +1.502017 · Nat Berhe · incremental -0.012017 · Michael Cox · incremental -0.012017 · Jerell Adams · incremental -0.022017 · Odell Beckham Jr. · incremental -0.052017 · Ryan Nassib · incremental -0.062017 · Eric Herman · incremental -0.092017 · Sterling Shepard · incremental -0.102017 · Cooper Taylor · incremental -0.132017 · Paul Perkins · incremental -0.152017 · B.J. Goodson · incremental -0.212017 · Justin Pugh · incremental -0.212017 · Weston Richburg · incremental -0.232017 · Bennett Jackson · incremental -0.232017 · Mykkele Thompson · incremental -0.232017 · Owamagbe Odighizuwa · incremental -0.262017 · Davis Webb · incremental -0.282017 · Jason Pierre-Paul · incremental -0.372017 · Jay Bromley · incremental -0.452017 · Dalvin Tomlinson · incremental -0.612017 · Avery Moss · incremental -0.682017 · Ereck Flowers · incremental -0.772017 · Evan Engram · incremental -0.802017 · Darian Thompson · incremental -0.852017 · Bobby Hart · incremental -1.162017 · Adam Bisnowaty · incremental -1.312017 · Eli Apple · incremental -2.652018 · Paul Perkins · incremental +0.062018 · Wayne Gallman · incremental +0.082018 · Zak DeOssie · incremental +0.142018 · Dalvin Tomlinson · incremental +0.162018 · B.J. Goodson · incremental +0.692018 · Landon Collins · incremental +1.412018 · Jerell Adams · incremental -0.092018 · Avery Moss · incremental -0.112018 · Adam Bisnowaty · incremental -0.132018 · Sterling Shepard · incremental -0.142018 · Evan Engram · incremental -0.172018 · Ereck Flowers · incremental -0.172018 · Davis Webb · incremental -0.212018 · Bennett Jackson · incremental -0.212018 · Mykkele Thompson · incremental -0.222018 · Owamagbe Odighizuwa · incremental -0.232018 · Odell Beckham Jr. · incremental -0.262018 · Eli Apple · incremental -0.782018 · Andre Williams · incremental -3.312019 · Zak DeOssie · incremental +0.112019 · Dalvin Tomlinson · incremental +0.112019 · Sterling Shepard · incremental -0.082019 · Evan Engram · incremental -0.132019 · Adam Bisnowaty · incremental -0.142019 · Davis Webb · incremental -0.212019 · Mykkele Thompson · incremental -0.212019 · Wayne Gallman · incremental -0.232019 · Owamagbe Odighizuwa · incremental -0.242020 · Paul Perkins · incremental +0.062020 · Dalvin Tomlinson · incremental +0.172020 · Wayne Gallman · incremental +0.742020 · Sterling Shepard · incremental -0.072020 · Jerell Adams · incremental -0.082020 · Avery Moss · incremental -0.122020 · Adam Bisnowaty · incremental -0.132020 · Davis Webb · incremental -0.182020 · Evan Engram · incremental -0.452021 · Sterling Shepard · incremental -0.032021 · Avery Moss · incremental -0.112021 · Adam Bisnowaty · incremental -0.122021 · Evan Engram · incremental -0.182022 · Sterling Shepard · incremental +0.012022 · Landon Collins · incremental +0.022022 · Davis Webb · incremental -1.632023 · Sterling Shepard · incremental +0.032023 · Justin Pugh · incremental -0.49Pierre-Paul -2.0Joseph -4.3Williams +2.4Amukamara -2.1Pierre-Paul -2.5Pierre-Paul -1.6Pierre-Paul -0.2Pugh -4.0Williams +2.4Pierre-Paul -0.4Jackson -2.1Pierre-Paul -0.2Collins +3.5Pierre-Paul -0.3Jr. -2.0Shepard -2.1Apple -7.1Pierre-Paul -0.4Apple -2.7Williams -3.320078 players200815 players200921 players201024 players201120 players201225 players201326 players201426 players201527 players201626 players201730 players201819 players20199 players20209 players20214 players20223 players20232 players
Above expectationBelow expectationJason Pierre-PaulGM total -25.3Jason Pierre-Paul by season -7.6

How much retained production did Jason Pierre-Paul return vs. his slot?

Each mark below is one player's model value above slot. Light gray marks are slot-similar peers: DEs drafted within ±5 picks of Jason Pierre-Paul since 2010 (19 players).The score is the retained production/value bucket from the pick-residual model: on-team AV plus AV-rate quality, adjusted for draft slot, position, and era. Opportunity snaps and league honors are excluded.

-1-0.50+0.5+1+1.5+2Model value above slot11. WattJ.J. Watt · model value +2.4+2.416. KerriganRyan Kerrigan · model value +0.714. QuinnRobert Quinn · model value +0.617. AllenJonathan Allen · model value +0.518. IngramMelvin Ingram · model value +0.316. BurnsBrian Burns · model value +0.316. CoplesQuinton Coples · model value +0.216. MorganDerrick Morgan · model value +0.215. McDonaldWill McDonald · model value +0.115. WalkerJalon Walker · model value -0.119. McClellinShea McClellin · model value -0.315. IrvinBruce Irvin · model value -0.417. StewartShemar Stewart · model value -0.513. GrahamBrandon Graham · model value -0.714. BarnettDerek Barnett · model value -0.714. DavenportMarcus Davenport · model value -0.819. LawsonShaq Lawson · model value -0.920. ChaissonK'Lavon Chaisson · model value -0.920. ClaybornAdrian Clayborn · model value -115. Pierre-PaulJason Pierre-Paul · model value -1.1-1.1
Jason Pierre-PaulSlot-similar peers (19)

Cumulative value over time

Year-by-year running totals since draft. Left axis = games started. Right axis = honors (Pro Bowl / AP1 / AP2). Pre-2013 picks have no games-started line because that comes from per-game snap counts (not available for older players). Honors extend back to 1980.

'10'12'14'16'18'20'22'24'2503977116154012Cumulative GSHonors count
Games started (cumulative) Pro Bowls AP1 All-Pro AP2 All-Pro

Full-career season history (16 scored seasons)

YearTeamGPGSSnapsSnap-zAVAV/snapPBAP1AP2
2010NYG1603
2011NYG161214
2012NYG161510
2013NYG11105750.347.0
2014NYG16161,0461.998.6
2015NYG885160.235.8
2016NYG12118431.578.3
2017NYG16161,0702.376.5
2018TB16169391.888.5
2019TB10105870.746.8
2020TB16169431.71313.8
2021TB12126010.9610.0
2022BAL14125260.5611.4
2023MIA, NO3030-2.800.0
20240000
2025TB3038-1.200.0

How to read this